Romance Novels: Can They Impact Our Mental Health?
If you’ve been in a bookstore or on social media recently, you may have noticed the prominence of romance novels. While their social acceptance is new, romance novels have been an escape for readers since the late 18th century when Samuel Richardson wrote Virtue Rewarded. Virtue Rewarded depicted a woman who overcame hardships to achieve her dream of wedded bliss. Such stories were motivating and hope-filled, teaching that we can overcome great adversity and trials to achieve growth and reach our goals. Romance as a genre is not inherently evil; however, there are sub-genres that should make us pause and think before pursuing a seemingly innocent escape.
Romance novels are front and center in our current culture and are read by men and women from adolescence through adulthood. According to modern culture, spicy (erotic) romance novels are a harmless, fun escape. These novels are touted as a healthy way to escape reality, reduce stress, alleviate anxiety, and improve romantic relationships. Erotic romance novels no longer have revealing, suggestive covers. Their colorful fun covers draw in many readers who are not expecting or developmentally ready for the content within. What harm could come from these books that our society tells us are safe and supportive of emotional and relational health?
Merriam-Webster defines pornography as “the depiction of erotic behavior (pictures, movies, or writing) intended to cause sexual excitement” (emphasis added). We often associate the consumption of porn with the viewing of sexual content and images and don’t include the lure of the written word. Placing erotic romance novels in the porn category reminds us of the dangers they can hold for readers. While written porn may be viewed as less harmful than visual porn, research shows that written erotica can have a profound and lasting effect on female consumers. Women crave emotional connection and written erotica provides that in a way visual porn cannot. The powerful connection between the emotional connection and the erotic content create an allure that pulls readers in time and time again.
Pornography, including erotica, poses a threat of addiction to viewers and readers. Like many addictions, pornography/erotica addictions are driven by a dopamine loop. In these loops, the stimulus (behavior/substance/etc.) creates a dopamine release that can be highly addictive and habit forming resulting in a desire for more that drives the user/reader to repeatedly pursue the stimulus and maintain the loop. The emotional and sexual pleasure provided by erotic romance novels creates this dopamine loop and can lead to a behavioral addiction.
Unfortunately, the dopamine bursts that readers obtain can have a negative impact on their brain, relationships, and life satisfaction. Readers can become dissatisfied with their real-life romantic relationships and natural dopamine levels. Addiction, even to erotic novels, tells us that the life/emotions offered by the addictive stimulus is far greater than what a life without it can offer. When we allow erotica to cloud our minds, we can view our own lives through a distorted lens. Dissatisfaction can lead to an inability to understand why our real lives don’t mirror those of the book characters.
Once we change our perspective, viewing erotica not as innocent fun but as harmful pornography, we can begin to make book choices that better support our mental, emotional, and relational health. Reading is a brilliant hobby that can be a healthy coping mechanism, stress reliever, and way to increase our empathy and understanding. So before you pick up your next read, take a moment to consider the impact that the book can have on you. Reading is relaxing, but it should be mindful fun and not a mindless escape.

